Skip to Content

Surf’s Up Blue Hawaiian Milkshake Shots

Surf’s Up Blue Hawaiian Milkshake Shots

Hosting a luau party? Here’s an idea for a tiny bite dessert that is yummy and in-theme: Blue Hawaiian Milkshake Shots. Originally, they were made during our Family Movie Night Luau and we called them “fish juice” to go with some schtick in the movie Surf’s Up 2. But they’re great for a regular luau party as well. Get your blender ready!

How to make Blue Hawaiian Milkshake Shots for your Luau Party

Affiliate links ahead! They cost you nothing, but help pay server fees.


Before you mix anything, you really want to make sure that your parfait glasses, bamboo straws and whipped cream are all ready to go. Ice cream melts fast, and you’ll need to serve these quickly!

You won’t need a regular sized straw for these, so it’s ok to cut them in half for serving. But check them to the size of your glasses before you do any cutting.

In your blender, put the ice cream, milk, dry Jello mix and blend until smooth. I really love the single-serving bullet-type blenders. This recipe will make exactly 6 shot glass milkshakes, and the clean-up is so much easier than the big bulky blender. Of course, if you’re serving a big crowd, bust out your big blender and double (or triple) the recipe.

Pour milkshake into each of the 2.5 oz parfait glasses to almost near the top. Gotta leave room for the next bit!

Top each milkshake shot with whipped cream and a Swedish Fish.

Luau party ideas to host a movie screening of Surf's Up 2!

Serve to your grateful party guests! It’s just the right amount of sweet treat…with a chewy fish snack after.

Paula Biggs

Owner at Frog Prince Paperie
Paula Biggs is a party planner, DIY crafter, and owner of Frog Prince Paperie, where you can find hundreds of party, craft and lifestyle ideas.


Monday 31st of July 2017

What a fun drink! I love the straws and the little fish addition :-) Definitely perfect for a luau party. Pinned.